A Brief History of the FBI’s Involvement In U.S. Elections

From BackStory With The American History Guys

“Just what is the role of the FBI when investigating politicians and did [FBI Directory James] Comey cross a line with a move that many are interpreting as interfering with a presidential election within two weeks of Americans voting? In this BackStory short take, the Guys talk to Yale historian Beverly Gage about the history of the FBI’s involvement in U.S. elections.”

Listen (15:54): http://backstoryradio.org/shows/short-take/

Constitution 101 Curriculum: High School Level

Constitution 101 is a 15-unit asynchronous, semester-long curriculum that provides students with a basic understanding of the Constitution’s text, history, structure, and caselaw…Each module includes detailed materials for classroom educators, as well as opportunities for guided discovery and practice and tools to check for understanding.”

Module 1: Constitutional Conversations and Civil Dialogue (Primary Source: The Constitution)

  • Define the differences between political questions and constitutional questions.
  • Identify the seven methods of constitutional interpretation.
  • Explain the importance of civil dialogue.
  • Explore the structural constitution—Articles I through VII of the Constitution.

Module 2: Principles of the American Revolution (Primary Source: The Declaration of Independence)

  • Define natural rights, rule of law, and popular sovereignty—the key principles at the core of the American Revolution.
  • Describe how ancient and Enlightenment thinkers influenced the development of many of the key ideas on which the nation was founded.
  • Identify the factors that gave rise to the American Revolution.
  • Identify key principles of the American Revolution in significant sources from the era.

Module 3: Road to the Convention (Primary Source: Federalist No. 10)

  • Understand Shays’ Rebellion and its influence on the Founding generation.
  • Describe the Articles of Confederation and determine what type of national government it established.
  • Discuss what the Founding generation learned from key state constitutions.
  • Explain why the Founding generation decided to write a new constitution.
  • Examine the key lessons in Federalist Nos. 10 and 55.

Module 4: Constitutional Convention and Ratification (Primary Source: Closing Speech at the Constitutional Convention)

  • Meet the framers of the Constitution and their influence on the new constitution.
  • Describe the main debates and compromises reached by the delegates at the Constitutional Convention.
  • Explore the key arguments advanced by the Federalists and the Anti-Federalists during the battle over ratification.

Module 5: The Bill of Rights (Primary Source: Virginia Declaration of Rights)

  • Define the Bill of Rights and explain why the Founding generation added it to the Constitution.
  • Identify the factors influencing the Founding generation’s move to add a bill of rights to the new Constitution.
  • Describe the rights enshrined in the Bill of Rights.
  • Describe the role that the battle over ratification (and the views of the Anti-Federalists) played in creating a Bill of Rights.
  • Describe how the 14th Amendment and later Supreme Court decisions transformed the Bill of Rights through the process of incorporation.

Module 6: Separation of Powers and Federalism (Primary Source: Federalist No. 51)

  • Define the separation of powers and explain how this system works.
  • Describe federalism, including how it functions within our constitutional system and how it affects our lives.
  • Identify where we see the separation of powers in the Constitution and why the Founding generation valued it as an important feature of their new system of government.
  • Identify where federalism is in the Constitution and why the Founding generation valued it as an important feature of their new system of government.

Module 7: The Legislative Branch: How Congress Works (Primary Source: McCulloch v. Maryland)

  • Explain the Founders’ vision for Congress and explore the key debates and compromises at the Constitutional Convention.
  • Describe the role that Congress plays in the national government.
  • Identify the powers that the Constitution grants to Congress.
  • Discuss how the Supreme Court has interpreted the powers of Congress over time.
  • Compare the Founders’ vision for Congress with how Congress works in practice.

Module 8: The Presidency and Executive Power (Primary Source: Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer “Steel Seizure Case”)

  • Discuss Article II of the Constitution and outline the requirements to be president, the election process, and the President’s primary powers and duties.
  • Examine the origins of the Presidency and describe the Founders’ vision for the  nation’s chief executive.
  • Describe how the President’s role in our constitutional system has changed over time.
  • Review the role of the Supreme Court and Congress in checking the President.
  • Define what an executive order is, understand the roots of the President’s authority to issue executive orders, and study the role of executive orders in our government over time.
  • Analyze competing constitutional visions of the Presidency over time.

Module 9: The Judicial System and Current Cases (Primary Source: Federalist No. 78)

  • Describe judicial review and explain it is a key component of the American constitutional system.
  • Describe judicial independence and explain why the Founding generation viewed it as an important feature of the federal judiciary.
  • Examine primary source writings on the Supreme Court in Federalist, No. 78.
  • Describe how a case gets to the Supreme Court.
  • Identify how the judicial nomination process works and how a justice ends up on the Supreme Court.

Module 10: The First Amendment (Primary Source: A Bill for Establishing Religious Freedom)

  • Identify the five freedoms protected by the First Amendment.
  • Discuss the First Amendment’s speech-protective rule.
  • Examine contexts in which the government has some additional leeway to regulate speech.
  • Analyze the First Amendment’s religion clauses and explore how the Supreme Court has interpreted them over time.
  • Explore landmark free speech and press cases and examine famous quotes. 
  • Examine historical examples of different people and groups asserting their petition and assembly rights and reflect on the methods available to you today.

Module 11: The Fourth Amendment (Primary Source: Speech Against Writs of Assistance)

  • Describe the origins of the Fourth Amendment and the Founding generation’s vision for this provision.
  • Discuss how the Supreme Court has interpreted the Fourth Amendment over time.  
  • Describe how the Fourth Amendment contributes to debates about individual privacy.
  • Analyze how the Supreme Court has applied the Fourth Amendment to new technologies.
  • Identify current areas of debate over the Fourth Amendment.

Module 12: Slavery in America: From the Founding to America’s Second Founding (Primary Source: “What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?”)

  • Analyze the compromises over slavery at the Constitutional Convention and discuss the the Constitution’s effects on how long the institution of slavery lasted in America.
  • Examine the Supreme Court decision in Dred Scott v. Sandford and explain its importance to American constitutional history.
  • Analyze the events that led to the Civil War by using primary sources to explore the voices that pushed for the end of slavery. 
  • Describe the protections contained in the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments and how they promote freedom and equality.
  • Discuss whether the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments represented a “Second Founding” for America.

Module 13: Voting Rights in America (Primary Source: Declaration of Sentiments)

  • Describe what the Constitution says about voting rights.
  • Identify who can vote in America during various periods in our nation’s history 
  • Explore the role of federalism in the context of voting and elections in America.
  • Discuss the groups that benefited from the 12th, 15th, 17th, 19th, 23rd, 24th, and 26th Amendments.
  • Analyze battles at the Supreme Court over the Voting Rights Act of 1965.
  • Describe the long battle over women’s suffrage, culminating in the 19th Amendment.

Module 14: The 14th Amendment: Battles for Freedom and Equality (Primary Source: The 14th Amendment)

  • Explain why the 14th Amendment was added to the Constitution. 
  • Identify the core principles in clauses of the 14th Amendment. 
  • Summarize how the Supreme Court has interpreted the meaning of the 14th Amendment.
  • Evaluate the effect of the 14th Amendment on liberty and equality.

Module 15: Article V and the 27 Amendments (Primary Source: Article V)

  • Describe the reasons that the Founding generation included a formal process for amending the Constitution.
  • Explain how the Constitution’s amendment process works, and why the founders made it so hard to amend the Constitution.
  • Identify the key periods of constitutional change in American history and outline factors that drive successful pushes to amend the Constitution. 
  • Describe all 27 amendments to the U.S. Constitution.

https://www.pbs.org/explore/civics

Rain Savers

This lesson offers a set of questions to connect students’ prior knowledge to the theme of citizenship by examining the attributes and actions of effective citizens. Students watch an 11-minute film about water harvesting to examine human influence on water collection and drainage, and design a one-pager to synthesize and visually present what they have learned.

Source

https://www.retroreport.org/education/video/rain-savers

Retro Report is a non-partisan, independent, nonprofit news organization.

Throughline: NPR – Pirates of the Senate

“In this episode, we look at how the ongoing battle over the filibuster’s future is in some ways a battle over its past.”

Podcast (52 minutes). Transcript included.

 

We the People Resource Center

From the Center for Civic Education

Students and teachers – use this companion website for the We the People: The Citizen & the Constitution Level 3 textbook (2016 edition) to electronically access important portions of the We the People student text, such as the Unit and Lesson Purposes and the Terms and Concepts to Understand.

You will also find content related links to primary sources, Supreme Court cases, multimedia, and websites.

Photo Ethics: A Photograph’s Integrity

From NewseumED

“This case study explores a photojournalist’s ethical duty to be fair, accurate and clear, specifically in regard to manipulating photographs.”

  1. Divide students into small groups.
  2. Have students read the scenario and discuss the options.
  3. Encourage them to come up with a consensus on the action they’d take.
  4. Have each group share their decision and explain their reasoning. Did they find other groups’ arguments compelling? Why or why not?

tags: fake news, media literacy

America 101 videos – Donkey for Democrats/ Elephant for Republicans

From History.com

David Eisenbach explains the origin of the donkey as a symbol of the Democratic party and how the Republican party and the symbol of the elephant came together.

America 101: Why a Donkey for Democrats? video (2 min.): http://www.history.com/topics/us-presidents/presidential-elections/videos/america-101-why-a-donkey-for-democrats

America 101: Why an Elephant for Republicans? video (2 min.): http://www.history.com/topics/us-presidents/presidential-elections/videos/america-101-why-an-elephant-for-republicans

Congressional Elections: Crash Course Government and Politics #6

From CrashCourse

Craig Benzine talks about the importance of congressional elections – the frequency of elections in the Senate and House, typical characteristics of a candidate, and the motivating factors our congresspeople follow to get re-elected.

Watch video (8:57): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qxiD9AEX4Hc&list=PL8dPuuaLjXtOfse2ncvffeelTrqvhrz8H&index=6

tags: incumbency advantage, patronage, pork barrel programs, ear marks, franking privilege

270towin.com

270towin.com: This website educates its audience on the Electoral College system through the use of an interactive Electoral College map for 2024 and a history of Presidential elections in the United States.

Better Questions – Better Decisions Voter Engagement

From the Right Question Institute

The BQBD Voter Engagement Workshop offers a free, simple, easy to implement, engagement nonpartisan lesson for any middle school or high school social studies teacher, history teacher, librarian, or educator who would like to engage students in thinking about the importance of the elections and voting process. 

http://rightquestion.org/voter-engagement/

About the Right Question Institute

“The idea for the Right Question Strategy did not originate in a laboratory nor in an academic study. We began our work with a dropout prevention program in Lawrence, MA, funded by the Annie E. Casey Foundation, when parents told us they were not participating in their children’s education because they “don’t even know what to ask.” Parents had identified a huge obstacle that prevents many people from thinking for themselves, from doing their own problem solving, from becoming more self-sufficient and from being able to see the “Big Picture” beyond their own lives.

It only took hearing that statement one or two…thousand times, and we finally got it. Eventually, we figured out that we had to find a way to teach people how to formulate their own questions. We’ve spent 20 years designing ways to do that as simply and effectively as possible and created the Question Formulation Technique (QFT).”

The Question Formulation Technique (QFT) is the outcome of years of work in developing and, most importantly, simplifying a straightforward, rigorous process that helps all students learn how to produce their own questions, improve their questions, and strategize on how to use their questions. In the process, they develop divergent, convergent and metacognitive thinking abilities.

Free teaching resources by joining the teacher network.

“I Side With” political ideology quiz

I Side With – Political Ideology quiz. Can take shorter or longer version of quiz. Matches up beliefs with the 5 major candidates and explains them all at the end. Many other ways to analyze results also.

https://www.isidewith.com/political-quiz

Carolina K-12’s Database of K-12 Resources

From Carolina K-12

This is a searchable database for lesson plans/ activities. Files are available in PDF format, and one must have Adobe Reader installed to access the materials.

Lessons: https://k12database.unc.edu/lesson/
Activities: https://k12database.unc.edu/activity/

11 Excellent Reasons Not To Vote

From New York Times, By Errol Morris

In this Op-Doc video, Academy Award-winning filmmaker Errol Morris speaks with young Americans about the merits of voting and why some resist.

New York Times Video (7:21): “11 Excellent Reasons Not To Vote” http://www.nytimes.com/video/opinion/100000001874355/11-excellent-reasons-not-to-vote.html

Related Op-Docs Article: “11 Excellent Reasons Not To Vote” By Errol Morris – Published October 30, 2012
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/30/opinion/errol-morris-11-excellent-reasons-not-to-vote.html

“Ask Not What Your Country Can Do For You…”

Author: Department of Education and Public Programs, John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum

Summary: John F. Kennedy’s inaugural address inspired children and adults to see the importance of civic action and public service.  His historic words challenged every American to contribute in some way to the public good.  In this lesson, students learn about the theme of President Kennedy’s inaugural address, civic action, and consider how it applies to their own lives.

Objectives:

Students will:

  • interpret and analyze a primary source document to gather information about President Kennedy’s speech
  • explain the quote “Ask not what your country can do for you…”
  • propose an idea for civic action in their own school or community

 

Changing Voting Age from 18 to 16

Author:  By the People – PBS

In this activity, students will write letters to their state and/or national leaders either in support or against a fictitious proposed constitutional amendment to lower the voting age from 18 to 16. While there is no current proposed amendment (at least none on the federal level), this is an opportunity for students to become involved in participatory democratic politics.

Objectives:

  • Students will gain an appreciation for citizen participation in government and politics.
  • Students will learn how to write an effective letter to a state or national legislator.
  • Students will develop effective argumentation and persuasion strategies.

Source:

https://www.pbs.org/explore/civics/

http://www.pbs.org/elections/kids/lessons/lesson_plan14.html

A Burning Issue: A Structured Academic Controversy Concerning Flag Desecration

By The McCormick Foundation

Is a Constitutional Amendment required to protect the U.S. flag from desecration? Students present a compromise resolution after they debate, deliberate, and analyze primary source documents, including the majority and dissenting opinions from Texas v. Johnson.

Deliberating in a Democracy Judicial Elections

By Jennifer Bloom and Kate McBride

Engage students in a Structured Academic Controversy in this lesson that focuses on developing deliberation skills using a proposed amendment to the Minnesota Constitution that would change the way Minnesota judges are elected.

This lesson from the Deliberating in a Democracy Minnesota project teaches deliberation skills so that conflicting views can be heard, understood, and valued. The lesson includes a reading about the pros and cons of judicial elections for increasing understanding of the issue.

Objectives

  • Students will learn the process of deliberation
  • Students will increase understanding of the tensions concerning the way in which judges are elected and the impartiality of judicial elections and the first amendment
  • Students will practice skills for democracy

Materials Needed

Procedure

See Deliberating in a Democracy Steps and Steps Video